I just watched another documentary on BBC iPlayer called ‘Truth about Fat’ on Horizon.
It’s interesting to know that so much work is being done in this field. Scientists have figured out that telling someone to do more exercise and eat less doesn’t help the individual and telling someone that it’s a question of will power certainly does not help. There is something powerful happening which was overlooked.
Scientists have found out that being obese is not down to character, it is down to hormones. There are two kinds of hormones that seem to control our hunger and our appetite. Ghrelin tells us about our hunger and Leptin tells us about our appetite and being full. This discovery is quite recent.
These hormones seem to control when we get hungry? How hungry we are? How much we should eat? When we eat? And what we eat? For obese people Ghrelin stays at a constant level, which explains why obese people feel hungry all the time. Leptin rises and drops back to a constant level after an obese person has had food. This explains why obese people never feel full. These two hormones were discovered less than 20 years ago. What’s interesting is that these hormones can be changed so that an obese person feels full and does not feel hungry all the time. There are operations in existence that do that. However those operations can only be performed on extreme cases.
Research is being done in this area so that a treatment that is accessible by everyone can be found.
What’s also fascinating is that scientists thought that all that we are i.e. how we live life and how we deal with problems, is totally the work of genes but now cases have shown that indicate that environment also plays a big part in shaping our lives. Experiments have been conducted on identical twins and fraternal twins. Since these twins are only separated by genes, it’s thought-provoking to understand what other difference can be between them. It turns out there are other differences that are caused by environment. It’s possible that a normal person is carrying a gene that could potentially make him/her fat however it depends whether that gene is turned on or not and this switch is controlled by the environment.
Another important discovery mentioned in the documentary was that it was down to the time a person spends in their mother’s womb that decides whether that person will be obese. It is 25% likely that you will be obese if your mother’s diet is un-balanced.
The documentary I watched: http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01dzfgb/hd/Horizon_20112012_The_Truth_about_Fat/
I watched the documentary recently and your post sums it up well, it’s a fascinating subject and there’s so much more we don’t know yet. As always it gets more complex than nature Vs Nurture, and instead becomes a mixture of the two
I agree with you, there’s so much more, we haven’t understood yet. I think where ever genes and environment are involved. Genes loads the gun and environment pulls the trigger.
that’s exactly right I think, good comparison. Thanks for reading my thoughts on it too
You Welcome. I haven’t watched ‘The Truth about Exercise’ yet. Will soon and probably radiate out some thoughts on that too.
I look forward to reading
Here is the promised blog post: http://zainullabiddin.wordpress.com/2012/04/27/thoughts-on-the-truth-about-exercise/
Pingback: Horizon The Truth About Exercise and Fat, My Thoughts | She Said…
What about the size of meals; pizzas hamburgers; drinks; chocolate use of salt etc
Obviously the size matters but the main idea under discussion is how people feel the need to keep eating while still feel hungry.
Also eating less does not always mean you’ll be healthy. We all have different bodies….Check out http://zainullabiddin.wordpress.com/2012/04/27/thoughts-on-the-truth-about-exercise/ to see what I mean.
Thanks for the comment…stay in touch
Barkers theory I think you’re referring the last paragraph, and I might be wrong but.. Operons are the genes that switch off/on these hormones..
hmmm Interesting….Nice to know this.
Why were there no obese people in austwich ( prison camp during the 2 nd world war …!)
I would think there were was a big gene pool then!!! Just stop over eating and forget genes , i am fed up with ‘obese people’ making excuses for simple greed !!
The problem doesn’t stop by eating less. Especially in this society. War time is an extreme situation. There are two states at which cells work. Either they reproduce like crazy, ( and reproduce the errors that got into the DNA as well) or they repair the genes. By eating more and frequently the cells reproduce like crazy, by eating less or fasting, the cells repair the genes. You’re right from there but when food is available so plentiful, some people find it hard to resist. This is in their genes.
Who knows what and how much food was given to people in prison camps? War times situations are different.
Another one for the MKA Research Association blog
How do I send it to your blog? Wouldn’t it be easier if you just copied and pasted the post with my name underneath onto your blog? Or just click on the ‘Press This’ button in the share field.